Anishinaabe Territory/Ottawa, November 19, 2026 – Yesterday, the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights reported to the House of Commons the results its clause-by-clause study of Bill C-223, the Keeping Children Safe Act, stripping the bill of nearly all its key protections for women and children experiencing family violence.
Introduced by Liberal MP Lisa Hepfner, the bill was intended to prevent judges from relying on myths and stereotypes, including allegations of “parental alienation” against survivors of domestic violence.
“Nearly all meaningful protections in Bill C-223 were either removed or amended to the point of becoming ineffective,” observed Suzanne Zaccour, Director of Legal Affairs at the National Association of Women and the Law. In particular, clauses related to parental alienation claims and reunification therapy were withdrawn from the bill.
“We are deeply disappointed that the government and committee members chose not to protect women and children from harmful allegations of parental alienation. Too often, protective mothers are punished for disclosing abuse and cut off from their children’s lives, for months or sometimes years, based on the assumption that the child’s fear of the father is due to the mother’s brainwashing. This bill was a chance to end that injustice, and the committee let it go,” added Zaccour.
The outcome is in tension with the government’s own commitments. In 2025, the House of Commons Standing Committee on the Status of Women (FEWO) recommended amending the Divorce Act “to prevent parental alienation claims from being misused in cases of domestic violence or child abuse and from resulting in custody reversals or no contact order against the preferred parent.” The government’s formal response, tabled March 25, 2026 and signed by Justice Minister Sean Fraser, stated: “The Government intends to support this bill with amendments.” However, the bill as amended was stripped of its core protections against parental alienation claims, so further reform is still required to address the committee’s findings.
Moreover, the government introduced an amendment that states that the bill will come into force by Order in Council, rather than on a specific date, which would make it possible for the government to never bring the bill into force. Former Bill C-21 (amending the Firearms Act) had a similar coming into force provision with regard to its key domestic violence protections, and the government has still not operationalized these provisions, nearly three years after the bill’s adoption.
Lack of solutions-oriented approach deplored
The committee chose to fully remove parental alienation clauses rather than amend them. “If the committee was not fully satisfied with the wording of Bill C-223, it could have drafted and considered alternatives with the same aim of protecting survivors. The government and committee members had over nine months to consider the best way to address the recommendation from the Status of Women committee to protect survivors from harmful allegations of parental alienation.” During its study of the 2019 Divorce Act reform (which came into force in 2021), the Standing Senate Committee on Legal and Constitutional Affairs had also recommended that the government monitor its impact and ensure a review of the law within five years.
NAWL is also concerned that the committee’s study did not include a balance of perspectives. In particular, none of the survivors who have shared their experience of being faced with allegations of parental alienation were invited to testify. “The committee’s choice not to hear from any survivor of these practices nor to adopt any solution to attenuate the problem doesn’t make it disappear,” said Zaccour.
This outcome comes less than two weeks after the government presented Budget 2026, which contained nearly four times as many measures benefitting primarily men as measures benefitting primarily women. “This government has committed to keeping Canadians safe as one of its key priorities, but we must remember that women and children are Canadians, too,” said Zaccour.
Children’s lives at stake
In September, the National Association of Women and the Law released Institutional Failures and Child Murder in Canada, examining the murders of eight Canadian children. In each case, a woman sought help from police, child protection or the courts and was dismissed or disbelieved. The report describes a “pro-contact” culture in which maintaining a father-child relationship can override documented violence, and in which mothers’ efforts to protect their children are recast as “parental alienation.”
Canadian research has also documented that the courts’ focus on “parental alienation” concepts leads them to disregard evidence of family violence, ignore children’s wishes and concerns, and penalize disclosures of violence.[1]
One important reform survives: removal of the “friendly parent rule”
Despite these setbacks, the committee retained one significant reform: the removal of section 16(3)(c) of the Divorce Act, the so-called “friendly parent rule.” “This provision, which requires courts to evaluate parents’ willingness to support the child’s relationship with the other parent, presents a catch-22 for mothers who are victims of violence: if they say the father is dangerous, they are blamed for not being supportive of the father-child relationship; if they say they support that relationship, their safety concerns become less credible. Removing this provision will meaningfully improve children’s safety in divorce cases,” explained Zaccour.
[1] Linda C Neilson, Parental Alienation Empirical Analysis: Child Best Interests or Parental Rights? (FREDA Centre for Research on Violence Against Women and Children, 2018); Elizabeth Sheehy & Susan B Boyd, “Penalizing Women’s Fear: Intimate Partner Violence and Parental Alienation in Canadian Child Custody Cases” (2020) 42:1 Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law 80–91; Simon Lapierre et al, “The Legitimization and Institutionalization of ‘Parental Alienation’ in the Province of Quebec” (2020) 42:1 Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law 30–44; Simon Lapierre & Isabelle Côté, “Abused Women and the Threat of Parental Alienation: Shelter Workers’ Perspectives” (2016) 65 Children and Youth Services Review 120–126; Suzanne Zaccour, “Parental Alienation in Quebec Custody Litigation” (2018) 59:4 Les Cahiers de droit 1073–1111; Suzanne Zaccour, “Does Domestic Violence Disappear from Parental Alienation Cases? Five Lessons from Quebec for Judges, Scholars, and Policymakers” (2020) 33:2 Canadian Journal of Family Law 301–357.


